Site icon onedemat.com

NCDs in India: Safer Than Stocks?

Non-Convertible Debentures: Safer Than Stocks?

Non-Convertible Debentures: Safer Than Stocks?

Introduction

Stock market giving you anxiety? Tired of your fixed deposits paying less interest than your neighbour’s water purifier EMI?

Then say hello to non-convertible debentures (NCDs)—a middle path between the drama of stocks and the dullness of FDs. These are fixed-income instruments issued by companies that offer higher returns than most bank deposits, without the mood swings of the equity market.

And the best part? Some of them pay you regular income while you sip your morning chai. Others just sit quietly in your demat and grow fat over the years—like a disciplined child.

But are they safe? Are they taxable? And which NCDs in 2025 are worth checking out?

Let’s decode everything, minus the jargon. Promise.

What Are Non-Convertible Debentures?

Let’s break the fancy name first.

Debenture simply means a loan you give to a company.
Non-convertible means this loan cannot be converted into shares. You’re not becoming a part-owner—you’re just the classy lender who gets paid interest.

So, Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs) are debt instruments that companies issue to raise money from the public. In return, they promise to pay you a fixed interest for a fixed period. Think of it like lending money to your ambitious friend, but this time, he actually has to pay you back—with interest, and on time (hopefully).

NCDs are listed on stock exchanges, which means you can also sell them before maturity. And unlike FDs, where banks act all controlling with their early withdrawal penalties, NCDs give you more flexibility (in most cases).

Why do companies love NCDs?
Because they get long-term funds without diluting their ownership or sharing profits. And investors love them because they offer higher returns than boring old FDs.

Simple as that.

Types of NCDs: Secured vs Unsecured

Now, not all NCDs are made equal. Some play safe, others play wild.

🛡️ Secured NCDs:

These are the good boys.
The company pledges its assets (like property, receivables, etc.) as security.
So, in case things go south and the company can’t pay, these assets can be sold off to recover your money.

Investor’s comfort level? High.
Returns? Decent, but not sky-high.
Example: Muthoot Finance has issued secured NCDs—safe, solid, and reliable.

🎲 Unsecured NCDs:

These are the daredevils.
There’s no collateral backing them. If the company defaults, there’s no asset to fall back on.

So why would anyone invest in these?
Because they offer higher returns to compensate for the risk. It’s the classic high-risk, high-reward story.

Investor’s comfort level? Lower.
Returns? Juicier.
Example: IIFL’s NCDs come in both secured and unsecured flavors—with the unsecured ones offering rates up to 10.5%.

In short:

FeatureSecured NCDsUnsecured NCDs
Backed by Assets✅ Yes❌ No
Default ProtectionHighLow
ReturnModerateHigh
RiskLowHigh

NCD vs FD: Who Wins the Fixed-Income Fight?

If you’re wondering whether to park your money in a Fixed Deposit (FD) or go the NCD route, here’s a no-nonsense face-off.

Returns:

NCDs punch harder.
They offer 2–2.5% higher returns compared to bank FDs. That’s like getting an extra plate of biryani every year without spending more.

FeatureNCDsFixed Deposits
Issued ByCorporatesBanks & Corporates
Interest RateHigher (8–11%)Lower (5–7%)
LiquidityModerate (listed, tradable)High (easy withdrawal)
RiskModerate to HighLow
SafetyDepends on credit ratingHigh (especially in banks)
Tax on InterestTaxed as per slab (no TDS)Taxed + TDS after ₹40,000
Tenure1–10 years or more7 days to 10 years
Exit OptionYes (put/call/trade)Usually premature penalty

Tax Angle:

The Catch:

Verdict?
If safety is your thing—FDs win.
But if you’re chasing higher returns and can handle a bit of risk—NCDs are your jam.

Why Credit Rating Can Make or Break Your NCD Investment

Imagine lending money to a friend. Wouldn’t you check if they actually return cash on time—or if they vanish like your gym motivation?

That’s exactly why credit ratings matter in NCDs.

What Is a Credit Rating?

It’s a score given by rating agencies like CRISIL, ICRA, or CARE, based on a company’s ability to repay debt. Think of it like a financial report card.

RatingWhat It MeansRisk Level
AAAExcellent repayment abilityVery Low Risk
AA / AGood, but not perfectLow Risk
BBBStill okay, but some red flagsModerate Risk
BB & BelowRisky territoryHigh Risk
DDefaultRun!

Real Talk from SEBI:

No AAA-rated NCD issuer has ever defaulted (yet). Lower the rating, higher the risk. So when you see “BBB-” on a company’s NCD, you’re playing in riskier waters.

💡 How to Use This:

Before buying an NCD, always:

You wouldn’t buy expired milk just because it’s cheaper. Similarly, don’t fall for high interest if the credit rating stinks.

Secured vs Unsecured NCDs: Choose Your Risk Wisely

Let’s say you’re lending money to two friends. One gives you their gold chain as collateral, the other just gives you a thumbs-up and disappears for Goa. That’s the difference between secured and unsecured NCDs.

🔐 Secured NCDs – Safety with Slightly Lower Returns

These NCDs are backed by company assets—like buildings, machinery, or gold reserves. If the company fails to pay, these assets can be sold to repay investors.

Example:
Muthoot Finance issued secured NCDs in 2019 to raise ₹100 crore. Since they’re secured, investors had legal backing.

✅ Safer
✅ Lower risk of losing money
❌ Slightly lower interest

🔓 Unsecured NCDs – Higher Returns, Higher Drama

These aren’t backed by any asset. If the company defaults, well… you’re in for some heartbreak.

Example:
India Infoline Finance offered both secured and unsecured NCDs. The unsecured ones paid up to 10.5% — higher than the secured options — but came with more risk.

✅ Higher returns
❌ No safety net
❌ Full faith in the company’s honesty (gulp)

Which One’s Right for You?

Investor TypeBest Fit
Conservative InvestorSecured NCDs
Risk TakerUnsecured NCDs
Goal-OrientedSecured + Cumulative payout NCDs

Don’t just chase returns. Know what you’re signing up for.

How Taxes Affect NCD Returns: Uncle Sam Always Gets a Cut

Ah, taxes — the invisible hand that grabs your profits. Unlike FDs that deduct TDS upfront, NCDs are a bit sneakier. They feel tax-free… until the I-T department shows up.

No TDS, But You’re Not Off the Hook

Here’s the thing — NCDs don’t deduct TDS (Tax Deducted at Source), even if you earn ₹50,000 or ₹5 lakh in interest. But that doesn’t mean you escape taxes. The taxman still wants his share — just that you need to report it yourself.

Tax When You Hold Till Maturity

Hold the NCD till the end of its term?
The interest gets added to your income and taxed as per your slab.

Tax When You Sell Early (Before Maturity)

Sold your NCD before maturity on stock exchanges? Then:

Smart Investor Tip

If you’re in a high tax bracket, your “9% NCD” might end up giving you post-tax returns of just 6.5–7%. In that case, tax-free bonds or debt mutual funds with indexation benefit might make more sense.

NCD Exit Options: Can You Get Out Midway?

So you bought an NCD thinking you’d hold it till maturity — but now you need the money. Or maybe interest rates have gone up and your 9% NCD doesn’t look so sexy anymore.

Don’t worry — NCDs aren’t jail time. There are exit options, but they come with conditions.

1. Sell on the Stock Exchange

Most NCDs are listed on NSE or BSE. That means you can sell them in the secondary market — just like shares.

Pros:

Cons:

2. Call Option (Company Redeems Early)

Some NCDs come with a call option, which gives the company the right to buy back the debenture before maturity.

Why would they do that?

What it means for you:

3. Put Option (You Exit Early)

This one’s for you. Some NCDs have a put option, which allows investors to sell back the NCD to the company at a fixed date.

Exit Tip:

Before investing, check if the NCD is listed, and whether it has call/put options. These small details can be life-saving when you suddenly need cash.

Public NCDs in 2025: Which Ones Are Worth a Look?

Now that you know how NCDs work, let’s look at what’s hot in the market. In 2025, several companies have come up with public NCD issues — and some of them are turning heads with double-digit interest rates.

But remember — higher return = higher risk. So let’s break it down smartly.

Top Picks with Safer Ratings

Muthoot Fincorp Limited

Why consider it?

IIFL Finance Limited

Why it stood out:

Moderate Risk, Moderate Return

Muthoottu Mini Financiers Limited

A smaller NBFC with a decent A rating. Not AAA, but not junk either. Good for investors wanting a little extra return with reasonable risk.

High Returns, High Risk (Proceed with Caution)

Chemmanur Credits And Investments Ltd

BBB- is just one step above junk rating. Sure, you might get a 10-11% coupon. But if the company defaults, that 11% becomes 0%. These are strictly for thrill-seekers (or deep researchers).

Pro Tip:

Always compare the credit rating, issue size, and the company’s business model before investing. For example, gold loan NBFCs like Muthoot and IIFL have historically shown better asset quality and repayment records.

Conclusion

In 2025, public Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs) present a mixed bag of opportunities for investors. On one hand, you have well-rated NBFCs like Muthoot Fincorp and IIFL Finance offering steady returns with lower risk, making them suitable for conservative to moderate investors. On the other hand, smaller or lower-rated companies like Chemmanur Credits offer tempting high-interest rates but come with significantly higher default risk.

The key takeaway is simple: don’t chase high returns blindly. Higher interest rates mean higher risk, and the safety of your capital should always come first. Assess the credit rating, the company’s track record, and the issue size before deciding. For most investors, choosing NCDs with good ratings (AA or above) and reputable issuers is the smart path to generate stable income without unnecessary risk.

NCDs can be a useful tool to diversify your portfolio with fixed-income options, but like any investment, it pays to do your research and match your choices with your risk tolerance and financial goals.

For easy access to the best NCDs and seamless investment experience, you can explore and invest through Angel One’s platform — simple, reliable, and investor-friendly.

FAQs on Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs)

Q1: What are Non-Convertible Debentures?
Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs) are debt instruments companies issue to raise funds. They pay fixed interest but cannot be converted into shares.

Q2: How do NCDs differ from Convertible Debentures?
Unlike Convertible Debentures, NCDs cannot be converted into equity shares. They remain debt until maturity.

Q3: Who can invest in NCDs?
Anyone looking for fixed income can invest, but it suits investors comfortable with moderate risk based on the issuer’s credit rating.

Q4: What affects the risk level of NCDs?
Credit ratings by agencies like CRISIL and ICRA indicate the issuer’s repayment ability. Higher ratings mean lower risk.

Q5: Can NCDs be traded before maturity?
Yes, many NCDs are listed on stock exchanges and can be traded, though liquidity varies.

Q6: What is the usual tenure of NCDs?
Tenure ranges from 1 to 10 years, depending on the issue.

Q7: Are interest earnings from NCDs taxable?
Yes, interest income is taxable as per your income tax slab.

Related Articles

Groww vs Angel One: Which Broker Is Truly Built for You?

Exit mobile version